TY - JOUR
T1 - Collective action towards risk management in informal urban areas in Medellín
T2 - COVID-19 lessons for reducing vulnerability and inequality
AU - Garcia Ferrari, Soledad
AU - Crane De Narváez, Stephanie
AU - Castro Mera, Wilmar Edgardo
AU - Velásquez, Carlos
AU - Bain, Amelia A.
N1 - Funding Information:
This work was supported by a British Academy Infrastructures of Wellbeing grant (UWB190128), as well as funding from the Scottish Funding Council-GCRF (University of Edinburgh Internal grant 278000 GCRF12), and an ESRC Impact Acceleration grant (University of Edinburgh Internal grant EDI-20/21-P0034).
Publisher Copyright:
Copyright © 2022 Garcia Ferrari, Crane De Narváez, Castro Mera, Velásquez and Bain.
PY - 2022/2/25
Y1 - 2022/2/25
N2 - Recent experiences of socio-environmental disasters in Latin America have demonstrated the ineffectiveness of the state as a social actor in the organisation, coordination and implementation of adequate public policies to face these emergencies. This affects the most vulnerable urban areas, leading to unequal levels of impact from crises and disasters within cities. As a response, local collective actions, led by citizens, have emerged to manage risks. In Medellín, Colombia, in the context of the current COVID-19 crisis, our research identified a diverse repertoire of collective actions within informal, vulnerable communities, including collaboration towards improving food security, sanitation, pedagogy for self-care and prevention, and financial aid. Although these actions have had limited scope within the context of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, they demonstrate the need to promote a more proactive interaction between society and the state, based on a series of agreed interventions, promoting the exchange of knowledge and articulation of actions in the production and improvement of informal urban areas. This research explores how these collective actions have developed through a set of semi-structured interviews with community leaders and key actors in Medellín, with a view to identifying lessons for state-community dynamics in relation to disaster risk management and achieving a more integrated approach to improving habitat conditions within vulnerable urban areas. This work demonstrates that vulnerable communities in informal urban settlements can actively address their exposure to risk through locally-oriented, bottom-up collective actions. However, key linkages with institutional frameworks are needed to strengthen state-community dynamics and facilitate sustainable, inclusive and equitable development in cities.
AB - Recent experiences of socio-environmental disasters in Latin America have demonstrated the ineffectiveness of the state as a social actor in the organisation, coordination and implementation of adequate public policies to face these emergencies. This affects the most vulnerable urban areas, leading to unequal levels of impact from crises and disasters within cities. As a response, local collective actions, led by citizens, have emerged to manage risks. In Medellín, Colombia, in the context of the current COVID-19 crisis, our research identified a diverse repertoire of collective actions within informal, vulnerable communities, including collaboration towards improving food security, sanitation, pedagogy for self-care and prevention, and financial aid. Although these actions have had limited scope within the context of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, they demonstrate the need to promote a more proactive interaction between society and the state, based on a series of agreed interventions, promoting the exchange of knowledge and articulation of actions in the production and improvement of informal urban areas. This research explores how these collective actions have developed through a set of semi-structured interviews with community leaders and key actors in Medellín, with a view to identifying lessons for state-community dynamics in relation to disaster risk management and achieving a more integrated approach to improving habitat conditions within vulnerable urban areas. This work demonstrates that vulnerable communities in informal urban settlements can actively address their exposure to risk through locally-oriented, bottom-up collective actions. However, key linkages with institutional frameworks are needed to strengthen state-community dynamics and facilitate sustainable, inclusive and equitable development in cities.
KW - Collective action
KW - Disaster risk management
KW - Social production of habitat
KW - Co-production
KW - Vulnerability
KW - Inequality
KW - COVID-19
U2 - 10.3389/fenvs.2021.726867
DO - 10.3389/fenvs.2021.726867
M3 - Article
SN - 2296-665X
VL - 9
JO - Frontiers in Environmental Science
JF - Frontiers in Environmental Science
M1 - 726867
ER -