Enhancing Radiocarbon Chronologies of Colonization: Chronometric hygiene revisited

Magdalena M. E. Schmid, Rachel Wood, Anthony Newton, Orri Vesteinsson, Andrew Dugmore

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

Abstract

Accurately dating when people first colonized new areas is vital for understanding the pace of past cultural and environmental changes, including questions of mobility, human impacts and human responses to climate change. Establishing effective chronologies of these events requires the synthesis of multiple radiocarbon (14C) dates. Various “chronometric hygiene” protocols have been used to refine 14C dating of island colonization, but they can discard up to 95% of available 14C dates leaving very small datasets for further analysis. Despite their foundation in sound theory, without independent tests we cannot know if these protocols are apt, too strict or too lax. In Iceland, an ice core-dated tephrochronology of the archaeology of first settlement enables us to evaluate the accuracy of 14C chronologies. This approach demonstrated that the inclusion of a wider range of 14C samples in Bayesian models improves the precision, but does not affect the model outcome. Therefore, based on our assessments, we advocate a new protocol that works with a much wider range of samples and where outlying 14C dates are systematically disqualified using Bayesian Outlier Models. We show that this approach can produce robust termini ante quos for colonization events and may be usefully applied elsewhere.
Original languageEnglish
JournalRadiocarbon
Early online date18 Jan 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Enhancing Radiocarbon Chronologies of Colonization: Chronometric hygiene revisited'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this