From Epistemic Contextualism to Epistemic Expressivism

In this paper, I exploit the parallel between epistemic con- textualism and metaethical speaker-relativism to argue that a promising way out of two of the primary problems facing contextualism is one already explored in some detail in the ethical case – viz. expressivism. The upshot is an argument for a form of epistemic expressivism modeled on a familiar form of ethical expressivism. This provides a new nondescriptivist option for understanding the meaning of knowledge attributions, which arguably better captures the normative nature of epistemic discourse than descrip- tivist competitors like invariantism and contextualism.