Prioritization of outcomes in efficacy and effectiveness alcohol brief intervention trials: International Multi-stakeholder e-Delphi Consensus Study to inform a core outcome set

Gillian W Shorter, Nick Heather, Jeremy W Bray, Anne H Berman, Emma L Giles, Amy J O’Donnell, Carolina Barbosa, Mike Clarke, Aisha Holloway, Dorothy Newbury-Birch

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

Abstract

Objective: Outcomes used in alcohol brief intervention (ABI) trials vary considerably. Achieving consensus about key outcomes can enhance evidence synthesis and improve healthcare guidelines. This was an international, e-Delphi study to prioritize outcomes for ABI trials as one step in a larger effort to develop an ABI core outcome set (COS).
Method: 150 registrants from 19 countries, and representing researchers, policymakers, and patients, participated in a two-round e-Delphi study. In Round 1, participants (n=137) rated 86 outcomes, derived from a review of the literature and a patient and public involvement panel, by importance. In Round 2, participants (n=114) received feedback on importance ratings for each outcome and a reminder of their personal rating before rating the outcomes for importance a second time. Seven additional outcomes suggested in Round 1 were added to the Round 2 questionnaire. We defined consensus a priori as 70% agreement across all stakeholder groups.
Results: Seven consumption outcomes met inclusion criteria: typical frequency, typical quantity, frequency of heavy drinking, alcohol-related problems, and weekly drinks, at risk drinking, and combined consumption measures. Others meeting the threshold were: alcohol-related injury; quality of life; readiness to change; and intervention fidelity.
Conclusions: This is the first international e-Delphi study to identify and prioritize outcomes for use in ABI trials. The use and reporting of outcomes in future ABI trials should improve evidence synthesis in systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Further work is required to refine these outcomes into a COS that includes guidance for measurement of outcomes.
Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs
Volume80
Issue number3
Early online date30 Jun 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 30 Jun 2019

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Prioritization of outcomes in efficacy and effectiveness alcohol brief intervention trials: International Multi-stakeholder e-Delphi Consensus Study to inform a core outcome set'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this