Resultant Luck and Criminal Liability

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)peer-review

Abstract

The problem of resultant moral luck — that is, the problem of whether and to what extent the results of an agent's actions should influence the blame or judgement that is due to her — is a familiar issue within moral philosophy. It also has important implications for the structure and practice of criminal liability: can the state justifiably impose liability on offenders for the harms that they cause, as well as for their actions, despite the fact that they lack full control over the former? This chapter aims to elucidate the philosophical issues underlying this question. It argues that, whilst actors are not independently culpable for the results of their actions, these results are attributable to them. There is thus no inherent objection to the state convicting offenders of causing harms; the material question is instead whether, all things considered, it is justified in doing so. Having argued that such a conclusion is not necessarily intuitive, the chapter goes on to argue that the state has good reason to impose criminal liability for resulting harm. This is because harm is a legitimate object of state communication about criminal actions, due to its importance to offenders, victims and the general public. However, convicting offenders of causing harm also risks exposing them to unjust societal treatment. The chapter thus concludes that, whilst offence definitions and even criminalization decisions should be sensitive to resulting harm, the legitimate extent of the influence of such harm is variable. In particular, it argues that different general considerations will typically apply to offences of attacking and endangering.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Structures of the Criminal Law
EditorsR. A. Duff, Lindsay Farmer, S. E. Marshall, Massimo Renzo, Victor Tadros
PublisherOxford University Press
Pages36-58
Number of pages23
ISBN (Print)9780199644315
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Publication series

NameCriminalization
PublisherOUP

Keywords

  • moral luck
  • moral philosophy
  • criminal liability
  • criminal actions
  • culpable

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Resultant Luck and Criminal Liability'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this