The Young Person’s Sir Walter: Scott and the Nineteenth-Century Child Reader

This essay will chart how, in the decades preceding the First World War, Scott was repackaged as a writer ideally suited for childhood reading. It will focus on school editions of Scott’s works, biographies of Scott for children or young adults, and adaptations of Scott for home reading.
It will open with a survey of Scott’s reception by child readers pre-1870, covering evidence for the popularity of Scott’s ‘adult’ works with children in his own lifetime, and the first children’s editions of Scott: prize books (1830s) and Cadell’s Readings for the Young from Sir Walter Scott (1840s). It will then examine prominent mid-century advocates for Scott as childhood reading, including William Spalding for whom Scott teaches ‘broad and manly and practical views’ and ‘cheerful and correct’ sentiments, and Gladstone who extolls Scott’s civilizing and spiritualizing power.
Such views prove influential following the Education Act of 1870 and Education (Scotland) of 1872, when Scott rapidly becomes a classroom staple via editions supplied by predominantly Scottish publishers (Nelson, Blackie, Chambers, Oliver & Boyd). These volumes simultaneously address two distinct audiences, the public school gentleman-in-the-making, and the working-class boy who is encouraged to see a commercially expansive empire as a means to self-realization. Thus, on one hand, they stress chivalry, muscular Christianity, and noblesse oblige, and, on the other, the penniless heroes of Quentin Durward and The Talisman seeking fortune abroad.
Educationalists struggle, however, to identify an entirely positive model among Scott’s protagonists and instead propose Scott himself as the hero of his own works. Scholastic prefaces often consist of a potted biography, and discrete child’s biographies of Scott are increasingly published for both school and home reading. These again address a dual public school and working-class audience. For the first, Scott embodies the code of chivalry: courteous, liberal, cheerful in the face of adversity, publicly minded, a friend to all classes, a father to his dependants, a lover of children and animals, a sportsman devoted to manly pursuits and the great outdoors. For the latter, Scott is the epitome of industry, energy, and self-abnegation.
The genuine juvenile appeal of Scott’s life is testified by turn-of-the-century adapters of Scott such as Samuel Rutherford Crockett. Earlier adapters like Harriet Gassiot (1870) explicitly model their versions on the Lambs’ Tales from Shakespeare, presenting them as tasters for the incontestably great originals. Crockett and his contemporaries, however, explicitly acknowledge that contemporary children are drawn to Scott’s life rather than his works and find his novels ponderous in comparison with Stevenson. Their vivid, pacey, playful retellings tacitly acknowledge the limited appeal of unexpurgated Scott for the modern child.
The essay will end with two questions. Firstly, Victorian and Edwardian educationalists present Scott as exclusively a writer for boys, yet contemporary surveys of child reading indicate that he was equally, if not more, popular with girl readers. What evidence is there of how he was read by girls? Secondly, do educationalists miss the true nature of Scott’s original appeal to children? Perhaps what appealed is the very powerlessness and passivity of Scott’s heroes, buffeted between rival representatives of an older generation. The Waverley hero is essentially a child.