In this article in the AI magazine, vol. IV, no.1, The Current State of AI: One Man's Opinion," Roger Schank puts forward various views on the nature of AI. In fact, there are enough opinions for four men. That is, the views advanced are contradictory. I agree with one of the Roger Schanks, and disagree with the other three. Schank hoped that his article would start a debate on the issues he raised.